4438-4446 rue Garnier vs 5189-5193 rue Garnier
Data as of November 1, 2026 · updated every week
5189-5193 rue Garnier is the older building (1900); 4438-4446 rue Garnier was built in 1924. 5189-5193 rue Garnier is assessed at $1,671,600, 11% more than 4438-4446 rue Garnier ($1,500,000). 4438-4446 rue Garnier has 3 building permits on record, 5189-5193 rue Garnier has 4. Neither is in a flood zone.
| 4438-4446 rue Garnier | 5189-5193 rue Garnier | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | 5 dwellings | 5 dwellings |
| City and borough | Montréal · Le Plateau-Mont-Royal | Montréal · Le Plateau-Mont-Royal |
| Built | 1924 | ≈ 1900 |
| Assessed (roll) | $1,500,000 | $1,671,600 |
| Since the previous roll | −21 % | +12 % |
| Welcome tax on that value | ≈ $27,326 | ≈ $31,616 |
| Lot | 211 m² | 218 m² |
| Floor area | 348 m² | 279 m² |
| Notice of deterioration | No | No |
| City’s right of first refusal | No | No |
| Heritage | Yes | Yes |
| In a flood zone | No | No |
| Building permits on record | 3 · Oct 2023 | 4 · Feb 2011 |
| Findings | 1 Serious 1 Check 3 Note | 1 Serious 1 Check 4 Note |
| Nearest metro | Mont-Royal, 800 m | Laurier, 840 m |
The full report for each address explains every finding and shows the full permit and value history.
Full report: 4438-4446 rue Garnier Full report: 5189-5193 rue Garnier